The Big (THUD) Transportation, Housing and Urban Development

Last week Steve Chabot U.S. Rep. (R-Ohio) added an amendment to the annual appropriations bill to prohibit federal spending on the Cincinnati streetcar. Most news organizations begin with something like News 5's headline "Chabot amendment would strip streetcar of funds". Misleading and lazy journalism.

Cincinnati Streetcar

Here is what I found out from a D.C transportation wonk: Most people and news services, at least in Cincinnati, are confusing two separate bills. One is the transportation bill and the other is the appropriations bill, which funds the transportation department. Chabot added his amendment to the appropriations bill and he would need to keep inserting it into every appropriations bill in the future.

What the full Congress did pass is a new surface transportation authorization bill, which is wholly different from an annual appropriations bill. Authorizations are multi-year bills (historically 5, though this one is only 2 thanks to everybody's unwillingness to generate any more revenue) which give DOT and its agencies authority to operate, set regulations and spend money. Appropriations bills are annual and simply set how much money an agency gets for that year and might include some restrictions for how that year's money can be spent.

So, what my policy wonk buddy told me is,

... the Senate has not passed a parallel appropriations bill, meaning that the House bill and its Cincy Streetcar amendment is currently meaningless."
He added,
"If, somehow, it (Chabot's amendment) does make it in, as I understand it, Obama has threatened to veto because DOT, FTA, LaHood & Obama admin have already invested political and financial capital in the project. I don't think there's a whole lot to worry about. There's a lot of confusion between the re-authorization and appropriations bills which Cincy media has fallen prey to and Chabot is taking advantage of it to burnish his anti rail credentials for November."

Big news?
Big THUD!!

[where: 45202] best place to learn how to live downtown cincinnati ohio the ethos of Cincinnati



  1. 513FacePalmTimes9:57 AM, July 02, 2012

    Typical Chabot. His accomplishments while in office are two wars(unpaid for), Medicare part D(unpaid for), and the Bush Tax Cuts(unpaid for) simultaneously. Yet he's worried about federal funds for a streetcar project.

  2. With all of the exciting progress happening in downtown Cincinnati: huge Fountain Square crowds, huge OTR crowds, best Fringe Festival numbers, big Final Friday & Second Sunday crowds, more restaurants in OTR that have 2 hour waits, casino opening up in less than a year, hotel 21c well on its way, The Banks resturants and bars full and busy every day, Great American Ballpark ticket sales their best since the opening year, it's incredible that he is literally betting against downtown.

  3. Thanks Bob. It's too bad that our local mainstream meda doesn't take the time to look into these major details.

  4. Shoddy reporting from the Enquirer? Shocking!

  5. I miss Kevin Osborne at CityBeat. He would have had a field day with this.